Isha Says INGREDIENT-LED REVIEWS

About Isha Says

An honest, ingredient-led Indian skincare and hair care review site. Here's how we work.

How we review products

Every review starts with the full INCI (International Nomenclature Cosmetic Ingredient) list, taken from the brand's own site or the pack itself — never from a retailer's summary. We identify the actives and, where the brand discloses them, their concentrations, then check the claims on the front of the pack against what the list can support, citing peer-reviewed research where it exists.

Each product is scored out of 5 against products that do the same job: a face wash is judged as a face wash, a sunscreen as a sunscreen. We weigh four things, in this order: formulation (is it well built for its job?), honesty (does the packaging match the ingredient list?), value (price against products that do the same job) and tolerability (irritants, sensitisers and allergens, judged against who the product is for).

Verdicts and the scores they cover
VerdictScoreWhat it means
Top pick4.5 and upAmong the best at what it does, at a fair price.
Recommended4.0–4.4Does its job well, with a small trade-off.
Good choice3.5–3.9Solid at its job for the right person, with one real caveat.
Decent3.0–3.4Does the basics; better options exist at the price.
Not recommended2.0–2.9Misleading claims or a real irritation risk outweigh what it does well.
Avoidbelow 2Hard to recommend to anyone.

A product that does its job well for the right person, with nothing misleading on the pack, scores 3.5 or more. Scores below 3 are kept for real problems: misleading claims, a real irritation risk, or a price far above products that do the same job.

Reviews also show the Amazon rating next to Isha's score. Buyers rate how a product feels to use; we rate what the formula can actually do. When the two are a point or more apart, the review explains why.

We assess formulas; we do not run hands-on trials. We do not accept product samples or payment for reviews, and our ratings and "Our Take" sections are our own editorial assessment.

Who is Isha?

Isha is the voice of this site, not a real person. Isha Says is an independent project, and its reviews are researched and written with the help of AI tools, working from primary sources — the brand's ingredient list, the pack and published studies — against the rubric above.

Prices and buyer reports

Prices on this site are the MRP — the maximum retail price printed on the pack. Retailers usually sell below MRP and change their prices daily, so the buttons take you to today's price instead. Value comparisons in our reviews use MRP, so every product is measured the same way.

Some reviews include a short "What buyers report" section: our own summary of recent Amazon.in customer reviews — texture, scent, irritation, results. It is written in our words from reading those reviews, reflects a small and recent sample, and is separate from our verdict.

Our commitments

  • No brand has ever paid for placement, a review, or a rating on Isha Says.
  • Products are ranked by formulation quality and value — not by affiliate commission rates.
  • If a product has serious concerns, we say so clearly — even if we have an affiliate link for it.
  • We update reviews when formulations change. If a brand quietly changes an ingredient, we'll flag it.
  • We will always be honest about what we don't know.

Affiliate links

The "See today's price on Amazon" and "See today's price on Myntra" buttons are affiliate links: if you click one and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Affiliate income helps keep the site running and the database growing. It does not influence our reviews. We apply affiliate links equally to all products, regardless of commission rates.

All affiliate links are marked with rel="noopener nofollow sponsored" as required by Google's guidelines.

Analytics and privacy

We use Google Analytics and Cloudflare Web Analytics to see which pages are read and which retailer buttons are clicked. Google Analytics sets cookies; we do not collect your name, email or any account details, and we do not sell data. You can block analytics with your browser's privacy settings or Google's opt-out add-on.

Why Indian skin specifically?

Most skincare content is written for Western skin tones, Western climates, and Western budgets. Indian skin is more melanin-rich, Indian climates range from humid coastal cities to dry northern plains, and Indian water is often harder than in European countries where many products are formulated.

These differences matter. Retinols may cause more post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH) on deeper skin tones. Heavier moisturisers may pill in Mumbai humidity. Some sunscreen actives leave a white cast that's less visible on lighter skin but very visible on darker skin.

We factor in these realities when writing reviews. Our skin type tags and concern tags reflect the Indian context.

Contact

Spotted an error? Have a product you'd like us to review? Found an ingredient in our database that's wrong? Reach out — we take accuracy seriously.